productswarm · Deskopen-agentos/productswarmLIVEbuilt Owner last acted 15m ago: labelled #1011 ready

The desk

Today's report

Daily report, Mon 2026-11-16: 9 PRs merged since Friday (M6's pull, push and diff, M7's engine and Desk panel, the M3 Brief); the M4 drill hasn't restarted although #936 was ruled Friday; 3 of 7 Goals and Areas have open work.

Asks

  1. #894: restart the M4 drill (launcher/swarm launch builder --issue 894) if [build] hasn't by noon?
  2. PR #1027 (M7): will you take it by hand once reviewed?
  3. #991, #992, #1007, #1021: close them, or allow the planner's gh issue close?
  4. #977: triage it (trouble misses merger merges under authority).

Monday check-in: Monday check-in, Mon 2026-11-16: M6 and M7 moved; M4 at risk (drill stopped since Thu); M1, M2, M3 and Engine host held with no open work.

Plan

M1 Daily report runs without the owner 0 open, 10 done

Nothing open under it.

M2 Merges under delegation 0 open, 9 done

Nothing open under it.

M3 The Desk shows the plan and the report 0 open, 10 done

Nothing open under it.

M7 The Desk shows what kind of work the swarm ships 2 open, 2 done

Area Engine host 0 open, 2 done

Nothing open under it.

Trouble

open-agentos/productswarm, from swarm trouble at 2026-11-16T17:52:44+00:00

Area open-agentos/productswarm#687 Area: Engine host

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track every working-day check runs on the host (none missed for more than one sweep interval) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a webhook starts a check within a second (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a nightly backup of `swarm.db` exists for each of the last 7 days (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#1029 M8: I hear back from the department without checking on it

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track **Hand trial:** on at least 3 working days, the planner writes a briefing next to the daily report on the report issue, before anything is built. I record after each one whether it passed the test below. (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track **The test:** after the briefing alone I can answer (1) what can the product do now that it couldn't at the last briefing, (2) which Goals moved, which stalled, and why, and (3) how many decisions wait on me and where. I mark each day pass or fail on the report issue, and it passes on at least 3 of the trial days. (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track **Built:** once the trial passes, `[daily]` produces the briefing every working day, and the Bridge shows it first, above the decisions waiting. (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track **Away from the desk:** the briefing reaches me somewhere other than GitHub or the Desk, as audio or a message. Which one is set by a ruling (below), and I use it on at least 5 working days. (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

  • PR #1033 approved at head; the merger left it for the owner: approved ask: touches `roles/planner.md`, and mattmcalister hasn't approved at head 888b0f2 (waiting since 2026-11-16, 6h)

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#683 M1: Daily report runs without the owner

Progress

  • in progress a daily report posts without the owner starting it (no report in the last 10 working days started by [daily] (swarm daily))
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the Monday check-in posts when the watcher is run at a Monday clock in a test (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the daily report and the check-in read `swarm trouble` (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#684 M2: Merges under delegation

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a go PR is built, reviewed and merged with no act of mine (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a protected-path PR merges on my approval alone, with no merge click from me (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a PR that needs a fix (changes requested, an overstep I ruled on, or a merge conflict) is fixed and merged without a hand start, whichever role wrote it (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track an unreviewed revert is refused, shown in a drill in the scratch repo (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#685 M3: The Desk shows the plan and the report

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track a fixed list of state questions, written as a Brief under this Goal, is each answerable from the Desk alone (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track that list is checked by a test against a fixture state, including cases that haven't happened yet (a stalled PR, a question waiting on me, a failed Area target) (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#686 M4: Readiness review

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the review is held against a checklist, written as a Brief under this Goal (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track one scripted drill in the scratch repo, under a Goal I open, runs to the end with no act of mine but opening the Goal, answering its question and approving its protected-path PR (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the drill includes: several Tasks built, reviewed and merged by the merger; a planted defect the reviewer catches (gate 13); a changes-requested loop on a PR the builder didn't write; a merge conflict; one protected-path PR; one `gov:question`; a pause of that repo alone (gate 19) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track my acts in the drill are counted and reported by `swarm acts`, with no budget (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the review's result is recorded on this issue (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#938 M6: Specs written in Notion ship through the swarm

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track `swarm specs pull` turns the Ready features of a Notion initiative linked to an owner-opened Goal into go sub-issues, each carrying a dated spec snapshot (#937 §5.2) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track `swarm specs diff` catches a real spec edit made mid-run, and the lead resolves it in the daily report (adopt, defer or ask) (#937 §5.3) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track `swarm specs push` writes status, PR links and one delivery comment per merge back to Notion, idempotently, as the `productswarm` integration (#937 §5.4) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track `swarm specs render` produces the run's page from run data alone, with no hand edits (#937 §5.5) (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track shown end to end once with the Effort mix initiative in Notion, run by hand twice before any `swarm watch` trigger (#937 §11–12) (no measure yet)

Stuck

  • #1007 PR #1009 merged, but #1007 is still open (since 2026-11-13, 3d)

Waiting on the owner

none

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Goal open-agentos/productswarm#987 M7: The Desk shows what kind of work the swarm ships

Progress

  • unmeasured: not known to be on track every merged PR carries an effort label, from the classifier or my `kind:*` correction (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the Desk shows effort per Goal and a capability-share trend by week (no measure yet)
  • unmeasured: not known to be on track the classifier passes its pre-registered pass mark on a held-out set I labelled, or the report says it doesn't and the `paths` baseline is used instead (no measure yet)

Stuck

none

Waiting on the owner

  • PR #1027 approved at head; the merger left it for the owner: 5016 changed lines, over [merger] max_changed_lines 500 (waiting since 2026-11-16, 0h)

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

Under no Goal or Area

Stuck

  • #991 PR #1000 merged, but #991 is still open (since 2026-11-13, 3d)
  • #992 PR #1001 merged, but #992 is still open (since 2026-11-13, 3d)
  • #1021 PR #1024 merged, but #1021 is still open (since 2026-11-14, 2d)
  • #249 the planner stopped: the next piece it needs has no issue yet, so nothing will start it (since 2026-11-16, 7h)

Waiting on the owner

  • #751 no label, and under no Goal or Area (waiting since 2026-11-11, 5d)
  • #760 no label, and under no Goal or Area (waiting since 2026-11-11, 5d)
  • #908 no label, and under no Goal or Area (waiting since 2026-11-12, 4d)
  • #909 no label, and under no Goal or Area (waiting since 2026-11-12, 4d)
  • #977 no label, and under no Goal or Area (waiting since 2026-11-12, 4d)

On the owner's authority, last 24h

none

not read: swarm acts: not synced here; `launcher/swarm acts` counts the owner's acts

On the floor

No session is working.

idle: builder 15 min

The watcher

watcher last published 6 h 28 min ago, at 11:24 UTC: these lists are as of then, and it may have stopped (it publishes only when they change)

  • held: #895, waits on an open issue
  • failed: #991 answer, error, 09:55
  • failed: #992 answer, error, 09:55
  • failed: PR #1000 review, error, 09:55

Grants in use

The merger is live.

Left for you

  1. #1027 Effort-mix label set and labelled data (#1011): left for you: 5016 changed lines, over [merger] max_changed_lines 500,
  2. #1033 planner: write the M8 hand-trial briefing beside the daily report: left for you: approved ask: touches `roles/planner.md`, and mattmcalister hasn't approved at head 888b0f2,

The merger's comments on PRs in the last 24 hours, each PR's latest, newest first; times in UTC. Other uses of delegated authority are in the daily report.

The wire

  1. Reviewer requested changes on PR #1027

Today in UTC, newest first: questions opened, the owner's rulings and lapses, records merged, the reviewer's requested changes and committees convened.

What the numbers say

The last 14 days in UTC; "this week" is the last 7. Under 3 merged PRs, decided questions or records a trend says "too few to tell": one or two values can't show a direction. A question is decided when the owner first adds gov:ruled or ready, or else when it closes.

How the questions went

56 questions asked in the last 14 days (from 3 Nov).

Asked by the owner: the owner opened it, or its "Raised by" starts with "owner". Decided by a committee: a committee Discussion serves it or its record's shape is committee; by the owner: the owner added gov:ruled or ready, it has a record, or it was closed without gov:lapsed. Became a record: a file in governance/decisions/ answers it; direction only: ruled or ready with no record, which is not precedent (GOV-0006).

Precedent in use

Record11-0311-0411-0511-0611-0711-0811-0911-1011-1111-1211-1311-1411-1511-16TotalAgentsOwnerBy reviewer
GOV-0041152···17893
GOV-0040·151··1171437
GOV-0039·121···131214
GOV-0038·5····5411
GOV-0037·5····5230
GOV-0036·72···9813
GOV-0035·2····2200
GOV-00348344····191637
GOV-003365141141··41291210
GOV-0032··14271····241958
GOV-0031··45546276··21311211062
GOV-003013·4·93····201646
GOV-0029292·3153····4335815
GOV-002852·1283····211924
GOV-0027437·33145160164·523321518139
GOV-0026305·14·······4942719
GOV-002541·323·····131123
GOV-00247··········7613
GOV-002329····2·····312929
GOV-0022334·2·1·····4031910
GOV-002127102··2·1431···5951813
GOV-002022198·3·······4329147
GOV-0019711············181715
GOV-001841422···1·12···261884
GOV-001761534··········282175
GOV-0016818·2····11····302466
GOV-001526726······1···423667
GOV-0014233872·2·32····5041913
GOV-0013188114···121····4535108
GOV-0012247·172·412·1···5850813
GOV-00113611214··22106···386731322
GOV-0010284·174·4·64····67561110
GOV-000931·1162···1·····514659
GOV-0008212·41·1··1····302647
GOV-0007379·241·3·16711··9991839
GOV-00063396301·32153····102891328
GOV-00059·22··········131032
GOV-0004132212·11422···302555
GOV-0003542···1·······121113
GOV-0002153932·114·2···403377
GOV-0001···8··········8712

A citation is a GOV-NNNN mention in an issue or PR body, comment or review, once per text, on or after the record's date. Signature lines, tracking issues, the digest issue and review comments on governance/ files don't count. Days are UTC; a blank cell is before the record was made.

Past committees

no record yet

no ruling recorded

no majority after round 2
  • 2 of 3 rounds
  • claude-opus-5-5, claude-sonnet-5-5 · §7.2 met
  • 49 minutes first to last post
  • swing: 3 of 3 seats changed
no record yet

no ruling recorded

no majority after round 2
  • 2 of 3 rounds
  • claude-opus-5-5 · §7.2 met
  • 6 minutes first to last post
  • swing: 3 of 3 seats changed
“Reviewer requests changes only for a numbered block-list finding with evidence that the builder can fix inside the PR's issue; overstep outranks red; draft, not intent, skips review; amends GOV-0011's red and amber; eval gate is an unannounced planted-defect PR”
dissent: proposer
  • 2 of 3 rounds
  • claude-opus-5-5, claude-sonnet-5-5 · §7.2 met
  • 6 minutes first to last post
  • swing: 3 of 3 seats changed

The needs-you list, sessions, open PRs, reviewer sweeps, v3 progress and spend are on Operations; the full decision log, open and lapsed gov questions, and every committee's round grid are on Decisions.